Science, Ideology, and the Media

Science, Ideology, and the Media

The Cyril Burt Scandal

List Price: $50.95



Bookmark and Share
ISBN: 978-0-88738-376-2
Pages: 447
Binding: Hardcover
Publication Date: 01-01-1991
Also available as:
Google eBook Paperback

Description

In 1976, five years after his death, serious charges were leveled against the distinguished British scientist Sir Cyril Burt. His research on the nature of intelligence was challenged as fraudulent by a number of respected commentators, among them Leon Kamin, Oliver Gillie, Ann and Alan Clarke, and Leslie Hearnshaw. The evidence they marshaled, and the charges themselves are examined here in scrupulous detail. Written as a straightforward defense of Burt, this volume also tells a second story: the intrusion of the mass media into science, the power of the new media, and the success of this invasion, which threatens to replace intellectual authority.

Convinced that a great injustice had been done, Fletcher examines each of the charges in detail, subjecting each of Burt’s detractors to a symbolic cross-examination. He exposes carelessness and errors of interpretation, and reveals areas of evidence the critics failed to take into account. Each interrogation ends with a list of questions that call for clear public answer. Fletcher’s closing argument calls for the restoration of Burt’s reputation, so that justice is done.

The broader significance of this case study goes far beyond the Burt controversy itself, and has implications for the conduct of science in an increasingly contentious social environment. Fletcher describes how ideology, in alliance with a receptive popular journalism and the media, is able to establish itself as a powerful third force in scientific discourse. The Burt Affair demonstrates what happens when the media establish a viewpoint that permeates not only the scientific community, but also entrenches that perspective so thoroughly in public understanding that its assumptions are not even questioned.



Editorial Reviews

“Twenty years after his death, and fifteen years after the first sensationalized media accounts of scientific fraud, Cyril Burt's credibility and place in history continue to be weighed . . . In his unabashed defense of Burt, Fletcher rebuts each of the main charges leveled against Burt, including the fabrication of twin data, invention of co-authors, and misrepresentation of his position on educational reform . . . Recommended for all audiences.”—T. J. Thieman, Choice

“Sociologist Ronald Fletcher here makes the most outspoken attempt yet to rehabilitate the reputation of Sir Cyril Burt (1883-1971), the British psychologist widely accused of publishing a fraudulent series of separated-twins studies, among other unethical practices. . . . Fletcher effectively exposes some of the rhetorical excesses of Burt’s critics and the one-sided and sensationalistic reporting of the case by the media. He reminds us that Burt, whatever his flaws, also made many positive contributions to British psychology.”—Raymond E. Fancher, Science



People Who Bought This Book Also Bought:


Related Topics


close

Customer Reviews Average Customer Review: Not yet rated

Write an online reviewand share your thoughts with others.
There are no reviews for this book yet!



Runtime error in merchant2/5.00/modules/log/malf.mvc @ [0000000c:0000047c]: modules/log/malf.mv: Line 290: MvEXPORT: Unable to write to file 'malf.log'. Miva Merchant: Fatal Error
Fatal Error

Miva Merchant has encountered a fatal error and is unable to continue. The following information may assist you in determining the cause of the error:

   Error Code: MER-LOG-MLF-00002
   Description: Unable to write to file 'malf.log'.
   Other Information: